Technology content trusted by users in Australia and around the world.
4,963 Articles | 29,986 Posts
Select Your Edition:  
Tweakipedia
A wealth of
tech information!

AU EditionYou are located: Home > All News > Business, Financial & Legal News > Oracle must pay Google's legal fees after unsuccessful lawsuit

Oracle must pay Google's legal fees after unsuccessful lawsuit

By: (more) | Business, Financial & Legal News | Posted: Sep 5, 2012 5:30 pm

The judge has smacked Oracle with a $1,130,350 bill payable to Google for its legal expenses incurred during the unsuccessful lawsuit. "Google was the prevailing party in this action. Oracle initially sought six billion dollars in damages and injunctive relief but recovered nothing after nearly two years of litigation and six weeks of trial."

 

oracle_must_pay_google_s_legal_fees_after_unsuccessful_lawsuit

 

It's not as much as Google would have liked--they asked for over $4,000,000--but a large portion of that was fees for an eDiscovery firm, something found to be not payable. Oracle objected the claim, saying they had brought a matter of great national importance, something that would protect them from the fees:

 

Oracle initially alleged infringement of seven patents and 132 claims but each claim ultimately was either dismissed with prejudice or found to be non-infringed by the jury. Oracle also lost on its primary copyright claim for Java APIs.... While it is true that a copyright issue presented, copyrightability of APIs, was of great importance to the computer industry, this is not enough to deny costs. The media attention following this case was due in large part because Oracle crafted broad, and ultimately overreaching, claims of copyright infringement. A close follower of this case will know that Oracle did not place great importance on its copyright claims until after its asserted patents started disappearing upon PTO reexamination (indeed, Oracle's first damages report barely mentioned copyright claims). Oracle did not bring its API copyright claim for the benefit of addressing "a landmark issue of national importance," but instead fell back on an overreaching (albeit somewhat novel) theory of copyright infringement for its own financial interests late in litigation. On these facts, Oracle has failed to overcome the presumption of awarding costs to Google.

 

It will be interesting to see if this ruling affects future technology litigation, for example the Apple v Samsung lawsuit. One thing is clear, the judge believes Oracle's lawsuit was pointless enough to award lawyer's fees to Google, the defendant in the case.


SOURCE #1

Related Tags



Further Reading: Read and find more Business, Financial & Legal news at our Business, Financial & Legal news index page.

TweakTown News RSS FeedDo you get our news RSS feed? Get It! Got a news tip? Tell Us!

Post a Comment about this news



Check out our
RSS feeds!
  • Upcoming Content: Western Digital Scorpio Blue (WD5000LPVT) 500GB HDD Review
  • Upcoming Content: Scythe Mugen 4 Tower CPU Cooler Review
  • Upcoming Content: NZXT Grid 10 Port Fan Hub Review
  • Upcoming Content: Western Digital My Passport Edge for Mac 500GB External HDD Review
  • Upcoming Content: PQI Air Card 4GB Wi-Fi SDHC Review
  • Upcoming Content: LaCie CloudBox 1TB Personal NAS Review
  • Upcoming Content: Star Trek: The Next Generation - Season Three (1989) Blu-ray Review
  • Upcoming Content: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) Blu-ray Movie Review
  • Upcoming Content: Whatever happened to Comodo Time Machine?
  • Upcoming Content: ADATA DashDrive Elite UE700 USB 3.0 Flash Drive Review
  • Upcoming Content: MyDigitalSSD BP4 240GB mSATA Review


Business, Financial & Legal News Posts

View More Business, Financial & Legal News Posts


TweakTown Web Poll

Question: What new stuff are you most excited to see at Computex Taipei 2013?

Cases, Coolers & PSU’s

CPU's

Gadgets

GPU's & Video Cards

Keyboards & Mice

Laptops, Tablets & Phones

Motherboards & Chipsets

New Tech

SSD's & Memory

Booth Babes

or View the Results

View More Polls

Forum Activity

View More Forum Posts

Business, Financial & Legal Press Releases

View More Business, Financial & Legal Press Releases